A One-Eyed Pony at Pony Finals? You Bet!

By Maggie Junkin

Not much surprises me in the pony hunter division anymore, but I have to say meeting Good2Go, aka “Levi,” and his owner/rider Nicole Farr certainly did. I was showing in the large ponies at the Charleston Summer Classic when I first saw Levi and Nicole. They were showing in the large pony division along with me.

Levi looked like many large pony hunters I have seen over the years--a beautiful bay pony, great mover, and cute jumper. But something else about Levi caught my attention. He was different than any other ponies I have seen competing in the division.

Levi was missing his left eye. 

When I first noticed this, Levi was going around the schooling ring like a pro, bending left and taking on all the jumps without a problem. I did a double take. I had to seek out Nicole to learn more about this remarkable pony and hear his story.

Nicole was kind enough to meet up with me for an interview.

Nicole is 17 years old and is from Orlando, Fla. She trains with Peggy Stevens of Brookmore Farms. Levi is 11 years old. Nicole and Levi have been a team for two years.

According to Nicole, Levi had a successful career in the children’s hunter pony division prior to his injury and went to Marshall & Sterling with his previous owner.

It was in 2014, before Nicole owned Levi, that he lost his eye in a pasture accident. Every attempt was made to save his eye, but it was not possible. Levi had his surgery at the University of Florida Large Animal Hospital.  

After his surgery, Levi had some time off. His personality had changed and he had become very ornery. Nicole decided to lease Levi for a year. In their first year together, Levi began to bond with Nicole and learned to trust her. He developed a sweet puppy dog personality. 

Nicole credits Levi for changing her riding personality as well. Levi is very sensitive to Nicole’s non-verbal communication. He reacts to her nerves and is very in tuned to her fears. Nicole had to learn to trust in Levi’s ability. 

Once she gained confidence at home, she had to learn to control her show nerves. “He has taught me to relax and realize showing isn’t that scary," she explains.

Nicole now owns Levi. They started doing the green pony division in 2017 and qualified for Pony Finals their first time out. 

This is Nicole’s first time doing the division and Nicole is very excited to go to Pony Finals. The Charleston Classic Horse Show was Levi’s debut in the regular large ponies, where he earned good ribbons and a first place in the hack.

I asked Nicole if she had any challenges doing the division. Nicole stated, “bending to the left is harder, but he is really good at the handy.”

I was also curious if Nicole has noticed any discrimination from judges. She stated that judges have been mostly supportive and a few have approached Nicole with kind words after her classes.

What is next for Nicole and Levi? Nicole will age out of the ponies this year. She plans to keep Levi and take him with her to college. She also hopes to move into the jumper ring next year.

Meeting Nicole and Levi was a real pleasure. Levi is an inspiration and Nicole’s love for this special pony is obvious. Their relationship shows that a trusted bond between rider and horse can go a long way towards success. I truly wish this team much fun in their future endeavors.

Good luck at Pony Finals, Nicole!  I think you and your one-eyed wonder pony are “Good2Go” and I am definitely rooting for you!


Maggie Junkin competes on the circuit with her horse, Tommy Bahama. She lives with her family, 5 dogs, and 3 cats in Jenkintown, Pa.